Interference & Memory Consolidation
Interference describes the phenomenon whereby learning a new motor task impairs the retention or consolidation of a previously learned motor skill. From a functional and applied perspective, this is undesirable because previously acquired performance may be compromised, forcing learners to regain skills they have already acquired. Consequently, the sequence and type of motor tasks performed during training or rehabilitation need to be carefully considered to minimize the risk of motor interference.
From a scientific perspective, however, interference provides a valuable opportunity to investigate the mechanisms underlying motor memory consolidation. Consolidation refers to the neural processes through which fragile, newly acquired motor memories are stabilized and transformed into long-term memories. Interference is thought to occur when two learning tasks compete for overlapping neural resources involved in memory formation and stabilization. By systematically manipulating the characteristics and timing of successive motor tasks, we can therefore gain important insights into the conditions that facilitate or disrupt motor memory consolidation.
Over the years, several conditions have been identified that promote retrograde interference, i.e., when learning a second motor task impairs the consolidation of a previously acquired one. Interference is most likely to occur when the two tasks: (a) involve the same muscles, (b) require muscle activation in the same movement direction, (c) both involve learning rather than merely performing an established skill, and (d) are learned within a relatively short time interval (less than four hours).
In our research, we demonstrated that interference is not restricted to the trained limb but can also affect the untrained limb [1]. It has long been established that learning a motor task with one hand can facilitate performance of the same task with the opposite, untrained hand, a phenomenon known as cross-education. While cross-education is generally considered beneficial, we were the first to demonstrate that this interlimb transfer also applies to retrograde interference: learning a second task with one hand can impair the consolidation of a previously learned task in the opposite hand. Thus, the beneficial transfer of motor learning between limbs can also have a detrimental side.
In another series of experiments, we further refined the concept of task specificity by demonstrating that interference depends not only on the muscles involved and the direction of movement but also on the type of muscle contraction [2]. Specifically, interference occurs when both learning tasks involve the same contraction mode, either isometric or dynamic. However, when one task involves isometric contractions and the other dynamic contractions, interference is substantially reduced or absent. Extending these findings to a more functional context, we were also the first to demonstrate that interference can occur during the acquisition of balance skills: learning a second, similar postural task can impair the consolidation of a previously learned balance skill [3].
Preventing motor interference
Since interference can compromise motor learning and retention, we have also investigated strategies to prevent or reduce interference. One promising approach is physical exercise. We demonstrated that a single session of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) performed before learning a potentially interfering motor task can prevent interference in both the trained and untrained hemispheres [4]. Although we did not directly investigate the underlying mechanisms, previous research suggests that acute exercise may enhance arousal and promote the release of several neurochemical and neurotrophic factors involved in motor memory formation and consolidation. These include norepinephrine, brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1), epinephrine, and lactate. Such exercise-induced responses may create a more favorable neurobiological environment for memory consolidation.
We have also explored strategies that directly target the cognitive processes involved in motor memory. For example, we demonstrated that providing contextual color cues during the acquisition of the first motor task and the subsequent learning of a second task can mitigate interference effects. Similarly, motor imagery of the previously learned task during breaks in the acquisition of the second task can prevent interference [5]. These findings suggest that interference is not inevitable and that relatively simple behavioral and cognitive strategies can help protect newly acquired motor memories.
Stimulation-induced motor interference – causal studies
While behavioral interference paradigms demonstrate that two motor tasks can compete for overlapping neural resources, they cannot establish which specific brain structures are involved in motor memory consolidation. To address this question, we use repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) to experimentally interfere with neural activity in specific brain regions.
Low-frequency rTMS can transiently reduce motor cortical excitability and disrupt ongoing cortical processes. This approach is often referred to as inducing a reversible virtual lesion, as it allows researchers to temporarily interfere with the function of a targeted brain region without permanently damaging the underlying neural tissue. If the targeted region contributes to the consolidation of a recently acquired motor skill, this temporary disruption should impair subsequent memory stabilization.
Using this approach, we investigated the contribution of the primary motor cortex (M1) to balance skill consolidation. Specifically, we applied repetitive TMS over M1 after participants had acquired a novel balance task, thereby selectively targeting the consolidation phase rather than the initial learning process. The results revealed a substantial impairment in the consolidation of balance skills, providing causal evidence that M1 plays a crucial role in stabilizing newly acquired postural skills [6].
In a subsequent study, we went one step further by investigating the neurophysiological mechanisms underlying this effect. We demonstrated that repetitive stimulation over M1 not only impaired the consolidation of balance performance but also prevented the normal up-regulation of intracortical inhibition. These findings highlight the importance of inhibitory processes within the motor cortex for the consolidation of newly acquired balance skills [7].
In our ongoing research, we are extending this approach to investigate how behavioral motor interference affects the up- and down-regulation of intracortical inhibition. By combining behavioral interference paradigms with neurophysiological measurements, we aim to better understand how competing motor memories interact with the inhibitory mechanisms involved in memory consolidation. We will share further findings as they become available.
1. Lauber, B., J. Lundbye-Jensen, M. Keller, A. Gollhofer, W. Taube, and C. Leukel, Cross-Limb Interference during Motor Learning. Plos One, 2013. 8(12).
2. Bugnon, M., J. Ruffieux, and W. Taube, Interference in ballistic task learning: refining the notion of specificity. Neuroscience, 2026. 592: p. 44-51.
3. Egger, S., M. Wälchli, E. Rüeger, and W. Taube, Interference of balance tasks revisited: Consolidation of a novel balance task is impaired by subsequent learning of a similar postural task. Gait & Posture, 2021. 84: p. 182-186.
4. Lauber, B., S. Franke, W. Taube, and A. Gollhofer, The Effects of a Single Bout of Exercise on Motor Memory Interference in the Trained and Untrained Hemisphere. Neuroscience, 2017. 347: p. 57-64.
5. Lauber, B., A. Kurz, A. Gollhofer, and W. Taube, Mental imagery and colour cues can prevent interference between motor tasks. Neuropsychologia, 2019. 124: p. 202-207.
6. Egger, S., M. Wälchli, E. Rüeger, and W. Taube, Short-term balance consolidation relies on the primary motor cortex: a rTMS study. Scientific Reports, 2023. 13(1).
7. Egger, S., M. Wälchli, S. Meyer, and W. Taube, Repetitive Magnetic Stimuli Over the Motor Cortex Impair Consolidation of a Balance Task by Suppressing Up-Regulation of Intracortical Inhibition. European Journal of Neuroscience, 2025. 61(11).
