Physical Activity & Pain

 

Can balance training help to reduce pain?

More than a decade ago, we made an intriguing observation: balance training can reduce pain in patients suffering from chronic neck pain [1]. This finding raised an interesting question: How can exercises primarily designed to improve postural control have such a beneficial effect on pain perception?

Around the same time, I experienced something similar myself. Following a lumbar disc herniation, conventional strength training was often associated with considerable pain. However, I noticed that when performing balance exercises concurrently, I could activate my muscles with substantially less discomfort. For example, performing biceps curls while standing on a balance board allowed me to train with considerably less pain than when performing the same exercise under stable conditions. This personal experience further stimulated our interest in exploring the relationship between balance control and pain.

Recently, we revisited this question by investigating whether balance exercises can reduce pain. To induce pain, participants underwent a cold-water immersion test, in which they had to keep their hand immersed in cold water for as long as possible. During this procedure, participants either stood quietly or performed a balance task on a balance board. Interestingly, balancing significantly reduced reported pain intensity and increased pain tolerance, with fewer participants withdrawing their hand from the cold water prematurely. These findings suggest that balance exercises may have an immediate pain-relieving effect, even in the absence of long-term training adaptations (Franziska Peier, Yves-Alain Kuhn & Wolfgang Taube, manuscript in preparation).

The brain's inhibitory system – understanding individual differences in pain resistance

Why do some people tolerate pain considerably better than others, even when exposed to comparable painful stimuli? To investigate this question, we compared cortical activity in healthy individuals with high (pain-resistant, RES) and low (non-pain-resistant, NRES) pain tolerance, as well as patients suffering from chronic pain and central sensitization (CPP).

Using continuous EEG recordings during a cold pressor test, we focused on beta-band activity, which is associated with inhibitory processes in the brain, including GABAergic mechanisms. Rather than examining average brain activity, we specifically investigated how beta activity evolved over time during painful stimulation.

Interestingly, the groups differed not in overall beta activity but in its temporal organization. Pain-resistant individuals showed relatively stable beta activity, with a predominance of low-beta activity, whereas non-pain-resistant individuals and chronic pain patients displayed a more pronounced increase over time. Moreover, moment-to-moment increases in low-beta activity above an individual's baseline were associated with a higher likelihood of withdrawing the hand from the cold water.

Notably, chronic pain patients showed a temporal pattern of cortical activity similar to that of non-pain-resistant healthy individuals. These findings suggest that pain resistance depends not simply on the magnitude of cortical activity, but on how neural activity is dynamically regulated during painful stimulation. They also highlight the potential importance of inhibitory brain mechanisms in understanding individual differences in pain perception and chronic pain (Franziska Peier et al., submitted).

Together, these findings provide an important neurophysiological perspective on pain regulation and further motivate our interest in interventions that can influence cortical inhibitory mechanisms.

The GABAergic system – a potential link between balance control and pain modulation

One promising candidate for explaining the beneficial effects of balance exercises on pain perception is the GABAergic inhibitory system in the brain.

Our previous research has shown that balance training improves the modulation of GABAergic function and intracortical inhibition[2, 3], and can also increase GABA concentrations in the sensorimotor cortex [4]. Interestingly, these same inhibitory mechanisms are closely involved in pain processing. In several forms of chronic nonspecific pain, reduced inhibitory capacities have been identified as an important neurophysiological characteristic. Dysfunction of the GABAergic system is therefore increasingly recognized as one potential mechanism contributing to the development and maintenance of chronic pain.

This connection is particularly interesting from a therapeutic perspective. Although medications targeting GABA-related mechanisms can be effective in pain management, their use is often limited by unwanted side effects, particularly sedation. Could physical activity, and balance training in particular, provide a non-pharmacological way of enhancing inhibitory mechanisms and thereby helping to regulate pain?

To explore this possibility, we investigated the effects of balance training in a 62-year-old individual suffering from widespread chronic pain [5]. We specifically examined whether improvements in intracortical inhibition, assessed using short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI), would be accompanied by changes in pain perception and overall well-being.

Following two baseline assessments, the participant completed two four-week periods of balance training, each separated by a two-month detraining period. We repeatedly assessed intracortical inhibition, pain intensity, sleep quality and mood throughout the study.

The results were striking. After the first four weeks of balance training, intracortical inhibition increased and its modulation became more pronounced. At the same time, the participant reported less pain, improved sleep quality and better mood. However, following the subsequent two-month detraining period, these improvements largely disappeared, with all measures returning towards baseline levels.

During the second four-week training period, intracortical inhibition increased even further, exceeding the levels achieved during the first intervention. Again, these neurophysiological changes were accompanied by further improvements in pain, sleep and mood. Following the second detraining period, however, the improvements once again largely disappeared.

Although these findings originate from a single-case study and therefore require confirmation in larger controlled trials, they provide an intriguing indication that changes in GABAergic inhibitory mechanisms may be linked to changes in pain perception. More importantly, they suggest that balance training may offer a promising approach to improving cortical inhibitory function while simultaneously reducing pain and enhancing sleep and overall well-being [5, 6].

From neck pain to lower back pain – translating findings into clinical practice

Importantly, our research has not been restricted to a single pain condition. We have extended our investigations from chronic neck pain to patients suffering from chronic lower back pain. Here, too, integrating balance training into a multimodal treatment approach has shown promising results, with improvements in both pain perception and sleep quality (Beinert et al., manuscript in preparation). Further studies are on the way with the ‘chronic pain & exercise’ group (CPE).

Taken together, our findings suggest that balance training may influence pain through more than just its mechanical or muscular effects. By challenging the sensorimotor system, balance exercises may engage and modulate central inhibitory mechanisms that are also involved in pain processing. Our EEG findings further suggest that the temporal dynamics of cortical activity are an important dimension of pain resistance and may help explain why individuals differ in their ability to cope with pain.

This provides an exciting perspective on the relationship between physical activity, brain function and pain modulation.

Our overarching goal is to better understand these neurophysiological mechanisms and to translate this knowledge into effective, accessible exercise-based interventions for people suffering from chronic pain. In this context, balance training may represent an interesting example of Sport as Medicine – using targeted physical activity not only to improve motor function but also to positively influence brain function, pain perception and quality of life.

 

 

1. Beinert, K. and W. Taube, The Effect of Balance Training on Cervical Sensorimotor Function and Neck Pain. Journal of Motor Behavior, 2013. 45(3): p. 271-278.

2. Mouthon, A. and W. Taube, Intracortical Inhibition Increases during Postural Task Execution in Response to Balance Training. Neuroscience, 2019. 401: p. 35-42.

3. Taube, W., A. Gollhofer, and B. Lauber, Training-, muscle- and task-specific up- and downregulation of cortical inhibitory processes. European Journal of Neuroscience, 2020. 51(6): p. 1428-1440

4. Liu, X., S. Scherrer, S. Egger, S.I. Lim, B. Lauber, I. Jelescu, A. Griffa, G. Gambarota, W. Taube, and L. Xin, Rebalance the Inhibitory System in the Elderly Brain: Influence of Balance Learning on GABAergic Inhibition and Functional Connectivity. Hum Brain Mapp, 2024. 45(16): p. e70057.

5. Lauber, B., A. Kurz, A. Gollhofer, and W. Taube, Mental imagery and colour cues can prevent interference between motor tasks. Neuropsychologia, 2019. 124: p. 202-207.

6. Taube, W., N. Mory, F. Peier, M. Mouthon, J.N. Chabwine, and B. Lauber, Balance Training-Related Changes in Intracortical Inhibition and Symptom Severity in a Patient with Chronic Neuropathic Pain: A Single-Case Study. Brain Sciences, 2026. 16(2).

7. Taube, W. and B. Lauber, Changes in the cortical GABAergic inhibitory system with ageing and ageing-related neurodegenerative diseases. Journal of Physiology-London, 2026. 604(2): p. 689-706.