EXRE Weekly Colloquium: Claire Field - The Value of Incoherence

Ouvert au grand public Conférence
08.05.2024 17:15 - 19:00
+ Mixte

I argue that level-incoherence has distinctive epistemic value in a specific set of epistemic environments: those in which it is easy to acquire justified false beliefs about normative requirements of epistemic rationality. I argue that in these environments level-incoherence is the rationally dominant strategy. Nevertheless, the idea that level-incoherence is always irrational has proved resilient. I evaluate three candidate explanations for the intuitive pull of level-coherence requirements of rationality, only one of which is the traditional view that epistemic level-coherence is a requirement of rationality. I argue that, instead, level-incoherence is a defeasible reason to undertake further inquiry and reexamine one’s beliefs, and this can explain why it has often been mistaken for a requirement of epistemic rationality.

Quand? 08.05.2024 17:15 - 19:00
En ligne

 Lien événement en ligne

Où? MIS 04 MIS04 4112 (Salle Jaeggi)
Avenue de l'Europe 20
1700 Fribourg
Intervenants Dr Claire Field, University of Zürich
Contact EXRE
Elisa Bezençon
Pièces jointes
Retour à la liste